Cs Lewis Liar Lord Lunatic Quote

3 therefore jesus is lord.

Cs lewis liar lord lunatic quote. Lewis states that jesus can only be one thing. 2 jesus was neither a liar nor a lunatic. This was the argument that lewis used to prove the divinity of jesus christ. If jesus was not whom he claimed then he must be a lunatic a liar or worse.

Trilemma and the trifurcate phrase lord liar or lunatic lll suggest a three way decision two of which according to the argument constitute a dilemma thus favoring the third. Lewis quotes quotable quote i am trying here to prevent anyone saying the really foolish thing that people often say about him. Lewis believed so and also believed that he had a very good argument for convincing people to agree. Structurally it might more accurately be viewed as a binary decision in which one of the branches is asserted to lead to a dilemma thus favoring the other branch.

Liar lunatic or lord. Liar lunatic or lord. Or you can fall at his feet and call him lord and god. The leaders thought he must be a liar or a lunatic.

Lewis following in the train of those who preceded him argued along these lines. He would either be a lunatic on a level with the man who says he is a poached egg or else he would be the devil of hell. Lewis is saying that for jesus to be wrong about being the son of god he d have to be a liar or a mad man. One version was popularised by university of oxford literary scholar and writer c.

The trilemma argument popularized by christian writer c s. He was certain that no one could seriously argue for or accept these alternatives and that left only his favored explanation. He was enlightened or perhaps experienced a glimmer of enlightenment translated it into the concepts of the jewish culture of his time thus calling himself the messiah. Lewis s trilemma is an apologetic argument traditionally used to argue for the divinity of jesus by arguing that the only alternatives were that he was evil or deluded.

Lewis in a bbc radio talk and in his writings. But let us not come with any patronising nonsense about his being a great human teacher. 1 if jesus were not lord he would be a liar or a lunatic. Marsden suggests that two major critiques have been leveled at lewis argument.

This argument has occasioned a good deal of discussion with major thinkers and biographers lining up on either side of the question of its validity. He was neither the sole lord liar nor lunatic. But this argument is unsound because the first premise is false because there s another option he was a legend and didn t really say these things after all. You can shut him up for a fool you can spit at him and kill him as a demon.

Some also refer to this argument as the mad bad or god view.